Serving Ohio, Kentucky and Indiana since 2003 Call or Text us at (513) 880-2290

513-880-2290

Sheppard Insurance Agencies
Sheppard Insurance Agencies
  • Home
  • About Us/Meet the Team
  • Insurance We Offer
  • More
    • Home
    • About Us/Meet the Team
    • Insurance We Offer

513-880-2290


  • Home
  • About Us/Meet the Team
  • Insurance We Offer

A little about the agency and the team members

20+ years of service symbolizing experience and loyalty.

Our History

Our Partnerships

Our History

Founded in 2003, Sheppard Insurance Agencies aims to provide individuals and businesses with affordable and reliable insurance coverage. Over the years, our dedicated insurance agents have expanded our offerings and grown our team to better serve our valued clients.

A scale balancing books labeled Ethics, Values, Integrity against a crystal, with words Honesty, Compassion, Accountability on a book.

Our Values

Our Partnerships

Our History

At Sheppard Insurance Agencies, our insurance agents are committed to integrity, honesty, and transparency. We prioritize our clients' needs and work tirelessly to establish long-term relationships built on trust and mutual respect, ensuring you receive the best insurance coverage available.

Businessman selects insurance options on digital interface.

Our Partnerships

Our Partnerships

Our Partnerships

At Sheppard Insurance Agencies, we collaborate with some of the top insurance carriers in the industry, including Allstate, National General, American Modern, Liberty Mutual, John Hancock, and many others. This partnership enables our insurance agents to offer a wide range of insurance coverage options, ensuring that our clients receive the best protection at the best price.

Licensed Agents on the Team

Sid Sheppard, Agency Principal

Joseph Doner, Life & Retirement Specialist

Esther Fischer, Sr. Associate Agent

Sid started SIA in 2003.  With a drive and passion for helping people manage their risks and protect them from financial catastrophe, he leads the team in that goal.  He oversees the operation and agent interaction with customers to assure we deliver exceptional advice and consultation, backed by solid solutions and insurance products.

Esther Fischer, Sr. Associate Agent

Joseph Doner, Life & Retirement Specialist

Esther Fischer, Sr. Associate Agent

Esther started her career in insurance and risk management when joining SIA in 2004 in the agency's infancy.  She helps people with all types of insurance solutions to protect them from the financial impact when things go wrong. She is a graduate of the University of Cincinnati and a life long resident of the Greater Cincinnati area.  

Joseph Doner, Life & Retirement Specialist

Joseph Doner, Life & Retirement Specialist

Joseph Doner, Life & Retirement Specialist

Joe helps clients construct a predictable and protected retirement approach, ensuring their future is secure. With the support of experienced insurance agents from Sheppard Insurance Agencies, clients can find the right insurance coverage to alleviate their concerns. After stressful working years, retirement should truly be worry-free.

Cassandra Colton, Jr. Associate Agent

Cassandra Colton, Jr. Associate Agent

Joseph Doner, Life & Retirement Specialist

At Sheppard Insurance Agencies, we collaborate with some of the top insurance carriers in the industry, including Allstate, National General, American Modern, Liberty Mutual, John Hancock, and many others. This partnership enables our insurance agents to offer a wide range of insurance coverage options, ensuring that our clients receive the best protection at the best price.

Chrystal Bolton, Jr. Associate Agent

Cassandra Colton, Jr. Associate Agent

Chrystal Bolton, Jr. Associate Agent

Chrystal joined Sheppard Insurance Agencies in 2025, bringing with her three years of previous experience as an insurance agent. With her strong customer service skills, she contributes to the agency's mission of delivering superior insurance coverage and solutions to protect clients from life's unfortunate events. In her free time, Chrys

Chrystal joined Sheppard Insurance Agencies in 2025, bringing with her three years of previous experience as an insurance agent. With her strong customer service skills, she contributes to the agency's mission of delivering superior insurance coverage and solutions to protect clients from life's unfortunate events. In her free time, Chrystal enjoys spending time with her family and participating in her children's activities.

Alana Howell, Jr. Associate Agent

Cassandra Colton, Jr. Associate Agent

Chrystal Bolton, Jr. Associate Agent

Alana is the newest customer service superstar at Sheppard Insurance Agencies. Since joining the team, she has seamlessly integrated into the teamwork culture focused on taking care of customers and helping protect them with appropriate insurance coverage solutions. A born and raised Cincinnati native, Alana enjoys spending time with fami

Alana is the newest customer service superstar at Sheppard Insurance Agencies. Since joining the team, she has seamlessly integrated into the teamwork culture focused on taking care of customers and helping protect them with appropriate insurance coverage solutions. A born and raised Cincinnati native, Alana enjoys spending time with family, her fiancé, sports, and discovering all that life has to offer.

Copyright © 2026 Sheppard Insurance Agencies - All Rights Reserved.

This website uses cookies.

We use cookies to analyze website traffic and optimize your website experience. By accepting, you authorize our use of cookies.

DeclineAccept