Serving Ohio, Kentucky and Indiana since 2003
Who We Are at Sheppard Insurance Agencies
Our History
Our Partnerships
Our History
Sheppard Insurance Agencies was founded in 2003 with the goal of providing affordable and reliable insurance coverage to individuals and businesses. Over the years, we have expanded our offerings and grown our team to better serve our clients.
Our Values
Our Partnerships
Our History
At Sheppard Insurance Agencies, we believe in integrity, honesty, and transparency. We always put our clients' needs first and strive to build long-term relationships based on trust and mutual respect.
Our Partnerships
Our Partnerships
Our Partnerships
We work with some of the top insurance carriers in the industry, including Allstate, National General, American Modern, Liberty Mutual, John Hancock and many many others. This allows us to offer a wide range of products and ensure that our clients receive the best coverage at the best price.
About Us - Meet the Team
Sid Sheppard, Agency Principal
Cassandra Colton, Jr. Associate Agent
Esther Fischer, Sr. Associate Agent
Founded in 2003, Sheppard Insurance Agencies is committed to providing individuals and businesses with affordable and reliable insurance coverage. Over the years, our dedicated team of insurance agents has expanded our offerings to better serve our clients.
Esther Fischer, Sr. Associate Agent
Cassandra Colton, Jr. Associate Agent
Esther Fischer, Sr. Associate Agent
Esther has been with the agency for over 20 years after graduating from the University of Cincinnati. She handles all types of insurance and is a great resource for customers and prospective customers.
Cassandra Colton, Jr. Associate Agent
Cassandra Colton, Jr. Associate Agent
Cassandra Colton, Jr. Associate Agent
Cassandra joined the team and entered the insurance world in 2021. Her knowledge and awesome personality are a cornerstone of our service to customers.
Chrystal Bolton, Jr. Associate Agent
Joseph Doner, Life & Retirement Specialist
Cassandra Colton, Jr. Associate Agent
Chrystal joined Sheppard Insurance Agencies in 2025, bringing with her 3 previous years of experience as an insurance agent, where she gained valuable insights into insurance coverage.
Joseph Doner, Life & Retirement Specialist
Joseph Doner, Life & Retirement Specialist
Joseph Doner, Life & Retirement Specialist
Joe helps clients construct a predictable and protected retirement approach, ensuring that their future is secure. With the support of experienced insurance agents at Sheppard Insurance Agencies, clients can find the right insurance coverage to alleviate concerns. Working years were stressful enough; retirement should truly be worry-free.
